
A Compromise Agreement is a legally binding document used to settle workplace disputes and provides a useful mechanism to terminate an employment relationship in a mutually agreed manner.
Subject to some limited exceptions (such as latent personal injury claims or claims to enforce the terms of the Compromise Agreement), the agreement settles potential claims arising from the employment relationship, in return for financial compensation.
Before signing, an employee must receive independent legal advice on the terms and effect of the Compromise Agreement. While there is no legal requirement for the employer to pay for this advice, there is a long standing convention that the employer will make a contribution to the employee’s legal fees.
A Compromise Agreement allows the parties a degree of latitude to tailor the contents of the agreement to suit specific circumstances. This may include requiring the employee to reaffirm the contents of post-termination restrictions and duties of confidentiality, the provision of an agreed reference, securing the return of company property or an agreement that neither party will make derogatory comments about the other.
The “without prejudice” rule
Discussions with a view to terminating an employment relationship and the signing of a Compromise Agreement should be entered into on a “without prejudice” basis. When the “without prejudice” rule is engaged, this means that the contents of said discussions and negotiations cannot be referred to in any future litigation.
However, the approach is not without risk as the “without prejudice” rule applies in relatively narrow circumstances. In order to attract the protection of the rule, discussions have to take place when there is an existing dispute between respective parties and with the genuine purpose of attempting to resolve same.
What is likely to amount to an “existing dispute”?
An existing dispute could mean that a grievance has been lodged or that a legal claim has been lodged, threatened or can be reasonably foreseen if the parties are unable to resolve their differences. Not every grievance will amount to an existing dispute and the contents of same will be highly relevant. For example, it might be expected that the grievance would refer to, or allege, an infringement of some kind of legal right, the suggestion of contact with the Labour Relations Agency (LRA) or indeed, more explicitly, a reference to the Early Conciliation process (as a pre-cursor to Tribunal proceedings) or the lodgement of actual Tribunal proceedings, if matters are not satisfactorily resolved.
Each case will turn on its own facts, but relevant case law has provided some indications as to what may, or may not, qualify as an existing dispute.
In Garrod v Riverstone Management Ltd [2022] EAT 177, Ms Garrod submitted a grievance alleging pregnancy and maternity discrimination, bullying and harassment. Her employer held a meeting with her during which her grievance was discussed, but at the end of the meeting they said they would like to have a “without prejudice” conversation. They assumed that Ms Garrod understood what this meant and in the course of the discussion, the employment relationship was described as ‘fractured’ and ‘problematic’ and offered her a severance payment. No agreement was reached at the meeting.
The employer went on to reject the grievance and Ms Garrod resigned. She brought claims of pregnancy and maternity discrimination, harassment, and unfair constructive dismissal. In her claim she referred to the meeting where the “without prejudice” offer was made and to the contents of that conversation. The employer argued that the conversation should be excluded from evidence on the ground of “without prejudice” privilege.
A Preliminary Hearing was held on the issue and the Employment Judge found in favour of the employer. Ms Garrod appealed to the EAT, relying on the 2004 case of BNP Paribas v Mezzoterro [2004] IRLR 509 (EAT), which held that the existence of a dispute is not proven purely by the fact that the employee has raised a grievance. The employee also argued that the attempt to rely on the without prejudice rule was a cloak for unambiguous impropriety, as her employer had tried to push her out of her job for discriminatory reasons.
The EAT dismissed Ms Garrod’s appeal and decided the without prejudice rule applied to the settlement offer made at the meeting on the basis that there was an existing dispute and that the parties contemplated or might reasonably have contemplated that litigation would follow if there was no settlement. The Tribunal appeared to be particularly persuaded by the fact that the contents of Mrs Garrod’s grievance was similar to the Tribunal claim she ultimately lodged, as well as the fact she made references to legal rights, ACAS (GB equivalent of the LRA) and the Early Conciliation process.
Conclusions
When used appropriately, Compromise Agreements undoubtedly provide a useful way of quickly and efficiently resolving difficult workplace disputes. However, the “without prejudice” rule can be difficult to navigate and if in doubt, early legal advice should be sought. At Elliotts Legal, our employment team can assist with the drafting of Compromise Agreements for employer clients and in the provision of advice to employees who have been offered a Compromise Agreement.


